There’s a wildly popular advertising campaign in Britain at the moment featuring talking Russian meerkats (no – really!) encouraging consumers to compare financial services. Now the European Commission seems to be taking a leaf from the meerkats’ book by setting up its own comparison site for credit rating agencies – which currently seem to be harried on every side.
Lack of transparency is the driver behind the creation by the European Securities & Markets Authority (ESMA) of the Central Rating Repository (CEREP). CEREP’s aim is to help regulators compare the performance of the ratings agencies that ESMA supervises and reduce the cost of information for market participants; there’s no get-out for the agencies and they’ll be held responsible for the accuracy and completeness of the data they supply.
Meanwhile across the water the United States Congress continues to quiz Moody’s and Standard & Poor’s over their failure to predict the collapse of the brokerage MF Global (LiveWire background here). According to the New York Times Dealbook, the dismal performance of the two big players was in contrast to that of the smaller Rapid Ratings, which – paid by investors rather than the companies it rates – had been warning about MF Global for two years.
Consumer credit rating is also currently in the spotlight in the States, where the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) is planning to include consumer reporting agencies (such as Experian or Equifax) and debt collectors under its non-bank supervision programme. “This oversight would help restore confidence that the federal government is standing beside the American consumer", said CFPB Director Richard Cordray – ominously, one might think.
Away from the regulators and in the industry itself, nimbler and more open newcomers present a further potential threat. Kroll Bond Ratings has recently released its methodology for rating American credit unions; with a mission to “restore trust in credit ratings” (LiveWire background here), transparency is Kroll’s trump card.
Now the Wall Street Journal reports (subscription required) that Kroll has also been hired for the first time to rate the established players’ nemesis: commercial mortgage-backed securities (CMBS). They should be worried; in a recent seminar conducted by the Centre for the Study of Financial Innovation, the investigative company’s veteran head Jules Kroll accused the Big Three of reckless irresponsibility, compounding their offence as “the enablers of the crisis” by refusing to apologise.
Perhaps it’s no surprise, then, that one analyst at least – Zack’s Equity Research – regards Moody’s fourth quarter results as “disappointing” or that Standard & Poor’s has decided to dispense with the services of Barbara Duka as head of its CMBS group. Taken all round, it looks as if what used to be a fairly stable marketplace is due for some significant disruption.
VIP Subscription » Gain access to all VIP magazines, reports and articles to support content purchases and information strategy within your organisation.
How can FreePint Help? » Tell us what you are working on, and we can talk with you about how we can help support the value of information throughout your organisation.
Tim is an independent information industry commentator and trainer with around 40 years' experience in the profession. His career has encompassed information management, writing, editing, training, government policy advice and corporate media & marketing.
Tim's also an information skills trainer, running courses on enquiry handling, abstracting & summarising, information packaging & presentation and information management. You can find details of Tim's training services at www.buckleyowen.com.
Besides working on VIP and LiveWire, Tim also edits the newsletter of the Press Database Licensing Network and writes for other publications including Information World Review and Library & Information Update.
A family of resources to help information workers be more effective, raise the value of information in their organisations and contribute to success. Read more »
More companies are adopting the cloud and finding they save time and money in terms of security management. Government worries about cloud computing relating to privacy, security and data flow may be overstated, and the cloud may eventually become more important to individuals than their personal computers.
Are you using Google or proprietary software to undertake business, client or competitor intelligence? If you are, but you're budgets are being squeezed then you might want to think about how you can use open source and free tools as part of your intelligence arsenal.
LinkedIn has recently purchased Talent Pipeline and now SlideShare. SlideShare is an invaluable tool for recruiters, business development managers and competitive intelligence researchers as it contains PowerPoint presentations, product plans and hard-to-find facts and insights.
Software solutions for social customer relationship management are the latest concern for organisations who are finding it difficult to pick the right one. Exploiting the results companies get from their customers is also proving tricky, and getting a full return on investment may be hard to achieve.
FreePint Family
Competitive intelligence on a budget