The British Library’s announcement of its ambitious programme to digitize the UK’s newspaper collection (http://www.vivavip.com/go/e29096) was swiftly followed by an attack from James Murdoch, accusing the organization of exploiting news which publishers were obliged to hand over in the first place, for commercial gain.
The newspaper archive was built upon a law, which permitted the British Library to demand copies of every printed newspaper in the UK. Once digitized, the archive will be available to the public as a paid-for service. As The Guardian reported (http://digbig.com/5bbspw) , Murdoch Junior argued that not unlike search engines (see http://www.vivavip.com/go/e27361 and http://www.vivavip.com/go/e27220 for NewsCorp’s battle with Google), the British Library will be offering access to their archives at a low cost and damaging the newspaper industry in the process.
Countering the argument that the archive is being made available for easier access by the public to historical information, Murdoch claimed that the ultimate aim was commercial gain and increased public funding.
According to the Guardian, James Murdoch was “very, very concerned about some of the approaches that they (the British Library) seem to be taking. But at the same time there is a dialogue with the library about it."
Is NewsCorp heading for another spat on a different front?
Murdoch’s argument that creative ownership, protected by copyright laws, should extend to the digital sphere has led to a debate in the press as to whether laws passed in the 18th century (i.e. the 1710 Statute of Anne, the first ever piece of copyright legislation) can be applied to the fast-moving technical world we live in today.
Some commentators maintain that the Murdochs have got it wrong – again – (http://digbig.com/5bbspx ), with the argument being that copyright is more than a legal instrument – it needs to be interpreted within a technological context.
Dr Ian Brown of the Oxford Internet Institute (http://www.oii.ox.ac.uk) makes a valid point when he
says that the existing copyright laws cannot be applied to our current digital times. Instead, he argues that copyright should be changed to allow users to copy, but to prevent them from selling copies on. This would re-interpret the law as providing an ”exclusive right to commercialise, rather than to copy”.
Meanwhile, the British Library, wary of the minefield surrounding NewsCorp’s publications, is currently only digitizing newspapers that were published before 1900, for which copyright has run out. Minus the Times archive, that is, since that archive has already been digitized by the publisher and is made available to the British Library for a fee. Do you get the feeling that we are swinging around in circles here?
VIP Subscription » Gain access to all VIP magazines, reports and articles to support content purchases and information strategy within your organisation.
How can FreePint Help? » Tell us what you are working on, and we can talk with you about how we can help support the value of information throughout your organisation.
Penny Crossland is the owner of CH Business Research, a consultancy specialising in investigative research and market intelligence. Penny conducts research projects for clients from a variety of industry sectors, including financial services, management and security consultancy, FMCG, publishing and retail. Fluent in German, she also translates academic papers and corporate material.
Before establishing her business in 2001, Penny was Research Manager at OC&C Strategy Consultants in London. Penny graduated from Bristol University with a degree in German and Politics and has a Masters degree from London University in contemporary German Literature. She became interested in all aspects of business information through working for an industrial market research company in New York.
A family of resources to help information workers be more effective, raise the value of information in their organisations and contribute to success. Read more »
More companies are adopting the cloud and finding they save time and money in terms of security management. Government worries about cloud computing relating to privacy, security and data flow may be overstated, and the cloud may eventually become more important to individuals than their personal computers.
Are you using Google or proprietary software to undertake business, client or competitor intelligence? If you are, but you're budgets are being squeezed then you might want to think about how you can use open source and free tools as part of your intelligence arsenal.
LinkedIn has recently purchased Talent Pipeline and now SlideShare. SlideShare is an invaluable tool for recruiters, business development managers and competitive intelligence researchers as it contains PowerPoint presentations, product plans and hard-to-find facts and insights.
Software solutions for social customer relationship management are the latest concern for organisations who are finding it difficult to pick the right one. Exploiting the results companies get from their customers is also proving tricky, and getting a full return on investment may be hard to achieve.
FreePint Family
Competitive intelligence on a budget