Better News for Less is the title of a white paper currently available for download from real time news provider Moreover http://w.moreover.com/ - something of an irony, this, as Moreover is currently facing legal action from Associated Press, which alleges that it is accessing and electronically publishing AP’s proprietary news reports without permission.
‘Unlike traditional content syndicators that resell proprietary information, Moreover's sophisticated technology continually scours the Internet to capture and distribute breaking news and business information from thousands of qualified, handpicked sources,’ Moreover claims. However this cuts no ice with AP.
‘The Associated Press spends hundreds of millions of dollars every year... providing original coverage of vital breaking news that cannot be obtained anywhere else,’ said AP’s Chief Executive Tom Curley. ‘When someone uses our content without our permission, they are free riding on our newsgathering.’ http://www.ap.org/pages/about/pressreleases/pr_100907a.html
According to Nancy Gohring of technology news provider IDG, http://digbig.com/4ttdb the case has similarities to the one which reportedly induced Google News to change recently from a link-based to a hosted service. Although Google still doesn’t believe it needs a licence to reproduce a snippet of the original story and link direct to it, Ms Gohring reports that it decided to go down the licensing route following legal action from another global news wire, Agence France Presse.
Should information managers and their end users care, so long as the news keeps coming in? Indeed they should.
Firstly there’s the issue of provenance. If you pick up a story that’s been reproduced by a third party, it’s only prudent to trace it back to its original source to ensure that it’s accurate and complete. Example: I picked up the Nancy Gohring article on Yahoo News via an RSS feed from Content Blogger; I tracked it back to the PC World website from which Yahoo had sourced it, and then checked on the relationship between PC World and IDG News as a final safeguard.
That’s a lot of clicks to confirm the integrity of one story – but it’s a necessary part of being a responsible infopro with a reputation to maintain. Better, perhaps, to take the Google News route http://web.vivavip.com/forum/LiveWire/read.php?i=477 with guaranteed access to the story in its original form, cutting out all the other versions?
But on the other hand, cutting out all the intermediate stages risks concentrating content in fewer hands – something that is currently exercising the European Commission, which is investigating the Thomson Reuters deal for possible adverse effects on the financial information sector. http://digbig.com/4ttda
It also raises questions about the 2.0 culture of actively encouraging comment on original reports – comment that can sometimes add value by assessing a report’s implications for a particular community.
VIP Subscription » Gain access to all VIP magazines, reports and articles to support content purchases and information strategy within your organisation.
How can FreePint Help? » Tell us what you are working on, and we can talk with you about how we can help support the value of information throughout your organisation.
Tim is an independent information industry commentator and trainer with around 40 years' experience in the profession. His career has encompassed information management, writing, editing, training, government policy advice and corporate media & marketing.
Tim's also an information skills trainer, running courses on enquiry handling, abstracting & summarising, information packaging & presentation and information management. You can find details of Tim's training services at www.buckleyowen.com.
Besides working on VIP and LiveWire, Tim also edits the newsletter of the Press Database Licensing Network and writes for other publications including Information World Review and Library & Information Update.
A family of resources to help information workers be more effective, raise the value of information in their organisations and contribute to success. Read more »
More companies are adopting the cloud and finding they save time and money in terms of security management. Government worries about cloud computing relating to privacy, security and data flow may be overstated, and the cloud may eventually become more important to individuals than their personal computers.
Are you using Google or proprietary software to undertake business, client or competitor intelligence? If you are, but you're budgets are being squeezed then you might want to think about how you can use open source and free tools as part of your intelligence arsenal.
LinkedIn has recently purchased Talent Pipeline and now SlideShare. SlideShare is an invaluable tool for recruiters, business development managers and competitive intelligence researchers as it contains PowerPoint presentations, product plans and hard-to-find facts and insights.
Software solutions for social customer relationship management are the latest concern for organisations who are finding it difficult to pick the right one. Exploiting the results companies get from their customers is also proving tricky, and getting a full return on investment may be hard to achieve.
FreePint Family
Competitive intelligence on a budget